Sean Penn has weighed in on the controversy round straight actors enjoying homosexual characters, describing administrators preferring homosexual characters for homosexual roles as a “timid and artless coverage”.
In an interview with The New York Instances, Penn – who received his second best-actor Oscar for enjoying overtly homosexual politician Harvey Milk within the 2008 biopic Milk – mentioned repeating such a job “couldn’t occur in a time like this”, including: “It’s a time of super overreach, a timid and artless coverage towards the human creativeness.”
Movie followers had been fast to share their ideas on social media about what Faucets and Mystic River star Penn mentioned, with many declaring that previously 12 months alone quite a few straight actors had appeared in homosexual roles.
“Nicholas Galitzine, Paul Mescal, Ethan Hawke, Josh O’Connor and Sterling Ok Brown are all straight males who performed homosexual characters up to now 12 months. What within the precise hell is he speaking about?” one X/Twitter consumer requested.
“Barry Keoghan didn’t twirl round bare together with his shillelagh out in Saltburn so that you can make this assertion,” a second wrote, noting the well-known scene from the hit 2023 movie the place straight actor Barry Keoghan, who performs a homosexual character, dances within the nude to “Homicide On The Dancefloor”.
And a 3rd, potential with their tongue firmly of their cheek, remarked: “Sadly, folks have let homosexual liberation and inclusion politics get in the best way of what Harvey Milk’s legacy was actually about: Sean Penn being nice.”
A fourth introduced out a basic Simpsons meme to specific their emotions.
The homosexual casting debate has been rumbling on for quite a few years, with stars comparable to Ripley‘s Andrew Scott, Insurgent Wilson and A Very English Scandal‘s Ben Whishaw, in addition to Physician Who supremo Russell T Davies, all voicing their opinions.
Chatting with PinkNews in 2021, Davies mentioned he believed “casting homosexual as homosexual now’s the appropriate factor to do” as a result of “homosexual is just not a efficiency”.
The creator of It’s A Sin added: “In the event you’re casting somebody, you need an actor who can painting falling in love or being duplicitous or being evil or being a drug runner or being a saint… that’s what they’re there to painting. They’re not there to behave homosexual.”
Final 12 months, he spoke out once more, saying he felt the necessity to preserve advocating for the casting of LGBTQ+ actors as a result of “nobody else” was.
“The rationale why I come out with such a robust unilateral assertion is solely to shift the argument. There are 57 dramas on the market being forged right now with out me in that room. So, one voice simply tilts the argument [and] permits extra folks to be say: ‘Lets forged homosexual right here?’”
However Pitch Excellent star Insurgent Wilson disagrees. It’s “whole nonsense [that] solely straight actors can play straight roles, and homosexual actors can play homosexual roles”, she mentioned.
“It’s best to be capable of play any position that you really want. However in comedy your job is to at all times flirt with that line of what’s acceptable. Typically you do step over it however, on the finish of the day, you are attempting to entertain folks.
“If individuals are at all times being secure and protecting, you’re not going to get good comedy.”