Whereas it is tough to know the way the story would have panned out in the event that they did take the boats, a number of followers are mentioning how navigating via Center-earth’s waters would have really been extra harmful. On the r/lotr subreddit, u/Shta_qrd posed the identical query, which was met with a number of rebuttals. On one hand, going by boat is boring, however hypothesis says it could even have been impractical due to nefarious forces.
Redditor u/THE-JACKAL-LIVES said, “They might have been sitting geese for the ring wraiths.” The Ringwraiths from “LOTR” are undoubtedly difficult and want an explainer, however this response is apt. Seeing because the Ringwraiths can fly and have immense powers, the Fellowship would have been destroyed very quickly in the event that they have been on a ship within the sea. By traversing throughout land, the Fellowship can disguise, particularly in Center-earth’s daunting mountains.
One other response, which is in keeping with the TikToker’s standpoint, is that the mighty however small Fellowship would have been killed by pirates. “A small group alone within the sea would not have an opportunity in the event that they bumped into a big corsair ship. They might even be seen to lots of [S]auron’s spies. I assume sure birds that fly over water could be working for him,” wrote u/Donkeylord_303. Talking of birds, many have mentioned that the gang ought to have summoned Eagles to fly to Mordor. Nonetheless, considering that the Eagles might have saved the day is only one false truth from “The Lord of the Rings” that you’ve got all the time believed.