The query of Sith ethics modifications relying on which model of “Star Wars” we’re discussing. Lots of the Outdated Republic video games, books, and comics from the Expanded Universe painting the Sith as a flawed group, however one which is not inherently evil. It is people who grow to be corrupted by the darkish aspect.
The Jedi have confirmed time and time once more that their very own doctrine is stuffed with holes. They’re so afraid of emotional connections within the prequels that they prohibit all types of attachment, and so they steadily permit themselves to grow to be pawns of the state to advertise peace and order. In “Star Wars: The Clone Wars,” we see what number of planets and star techniques endure below Republic neglect. That is why a number of joined the Separatists below Rely Dooku. And simply as there have been well-meaning Separatists, so too might there be good Sith.
The present canon has erased a number of that nuance, sadly. Today, the darkish aspect is extra typically portrayed as a universally corrupting energy, although there are nonetheless a handful of exceptions. Regardless of that, it is clear that Sith concepts aren’t actually the basis of the issue. Finally, the Sith doctrine of embracing ardour, like most Jedi dogma, is only a software, made good or dangerous by whoever wields it. Although the darkish aspect will all the time be harmful, the Republic was proper to elevate its ban on all apply of the Sith faith.